Is it time to replace the roof? It may seem like a big decision, but choosing your new roof doesn’t have to be complex. Understanding the key differences between architectural shingles and metal roofs can help you figure out which option is best for you and your home.
Architectural shingles are the most common roofing material for U.S. households, but metal roofing is fast gaining popularity. Both are solid options for different reasons.
In general, metal roofing is more durable and has a longer lifespan of about 50 years, while architectural shingles last from 20 to 30 years—up to 40 years when premium architectural shingles are used. Metal roofing has a higher upfront cost, but it often comes out on top when considering the total cost of ownership over time.
Since each style has strengths and weaknesses, learning about the various roofing components can give you the confidence to pick the right roof for your house.
From lifespan to maintenance, we’ll explain the differences between architectural shingles and a metal roof. Roofing professionals like Erie Home can also give you estimates for each type of roofing option, helping you better determine which style best suits your needs.
In This Article
Lifespan
The lifespan of architectural shingles is shorter than that of a metal roof, but they’re durable and are often a more affordable option. Roofs constructed with architectural shingles can last from 20 to 40 years, but a number of factors impact the maximum longevity of this layered and bonded material.
One of the many benefits of a metal roof is its long lifespan: up to 50 years. Though all roofs are somewhat influenced by outside factors such as extreme weather, a metal roof is strong and durable and can withstand more than the average shingled roof.
For instance, stone-coated steel metal shingles from Erie Home are designed to resist wind speeds of up to 120 mph, while also protecting against advanced aging and discoloration. Erie Home metal roofs are also rated class 4 for hail resistance.
Here are a few points to remember regarding the lifespan of roofing:
- Environment – The environment your roof is regularly exposed to can influence how long your roof lasts. If your house is often in the path of storms with heavy rains or high winds, roof deterioration could occur faster. For example, missing or broken shingles can lead to roof leaks.
- Quality of Materials – Architectural shingles are only as good as the material itself. By definition, architectural shingles refer to the advanced process of creating a stylish shingle. Shingles can be constructed with wood, asphalt, slate, clay, or metal.
For example, an architectural shingle made from asphalt has two layers of asphalt bonded together, which, when installed properly, results in a thicker, more textured roof. Invest in roofing professionals who warranty their workmanship and the materials they use. - Installation – How a roof is installed can impact its lifespan. An improper installation could lead to inadequate roof ventilation or missing flashing. These missteps could lead to damaged shingles and overall roof damage.
- Maintenance – A well-maintained roof lasts longer than a neglected one. Regular cleaning and repairs can help lengthen the life of your shingle or metal roof.
Value
Architectural asphalt shingles typically cost less than metal roofs, but multiple factors can affect the overall cost of a roof replacement. The size, pitch, and shape of the roof greatly determine the final cost since most roofing materials are priced based on square footage. Additionally, labor and ease of access to the roof factor into the total cost as well.
Although a metal roof may have higher upfront costs, it can increase the value of your home, decrease energy costs, reduce maintenance and repair needs, and save you money in the long run.
Aesthetics
Architectural shingles are popular, in part, because of the desired aesthetics. The 3-D design gives your home a stylish, finished look. These shingles are available in a variety of colors, so you can choose a color that complements the rest of your home. Whether you use asphalt, wood, or metal shingles, the layered look adds dimension to the resulting roof.
If you’re unfamiliar with modern-day metal roofing, curb appeal may not be your first thought when considering a metal roof replacement. However, there are a few metal roof options that can add style and panache to your property.
Take, for instance, Erie Home stone-coated metal shingles. Crafted from steel panels, these shingles are cut and coated with crushed stone. This type of metal roofing provides an architectural shingle design with the durability and lifespan of metal.
Maintenance
All roofs require some form of maintenance to ensure their materials last as long as possible. However, some roofing materials are easier to maintain than others, and this can also depend on where you live.
Architectural shingles made with traditional asphalt require regular cleaning and inspection to stay on top of possible repairs. Whether shingles are cracked or warped, unwanted moisture or heat can become trapped under the shingle, causing roof damage over time.
Metal roofs don’t require as much maintenance as wood or asphalt, but you’ll still want to regularly inspect your roof to keep optimum coverage, and it’s a good idea to check your roof and gutters after every storm or high-wind activity.
Final Thoughts
Contact a roofing professional to talk over architectural shingles versus a metal roof, and to learn which option is best for your house. Since roofing options range in price, style, longevity, and function, there are a number of questions to ask yourself before choosing the final product.
Erie Home roofs are backed by a limited lifetime transferable warranty (30 years for asphalt roofing and 50 years for metal roofing), giving you the peace of mind of knowing your home is protected for decades to come. Call us today at 1-800-998-8301 for a free consultation and to learn more.Â
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it better to get a metal roof or shingles?
It depends on the type of shingles. Metal is one of the most durable roofing materials, featuring high-impact resistance to hail, high winds, and torrential rains. It’s also energy-efficient and can help keep your house cool in the summer and warmer in the winter.
Traditional asphalt shingles are a solid, consistent choice for roofing and are the more affordable option.
What are the disadvantages of a metal roof?
The main disadvantage of a metal roof is the upfront, out-of-pocket costs. Though you’re paying for quality, this can create a tight budget in the short term.
However, since metal roofs require less maintenance and often raise the value of your property, they tend to pay for themselves over time. Erie Home offers affordable financing options to help homeowners manage the cost of a metal roof.
How much more is a metal roof than architectural shingles?
A metal roof typically costs about two to three times more than architectural shingles. The exact price difference can vary depending on factors like the type of metal used (e.g., aluminum, steel, copper), the complexity of the roof design, and regional labor costs.
While the initial investment is higher, metal roofs offer longer durability (up to 50 years) and less maintenance, potentially making them more cost-effective in the long term.
Do metal roofs increase value?
Yes, metal roofs can increase a home’s value. They are highly durable, energy-efficient, and require little maintenance, which are appealing attributes for potential buyers.
Metal roofs can also improve a home’s curb appeal with a modern look and a variety of finishes. Additionally, their ability to withstand severe weather can be a significant selling point in areas prone to extreme conditions. This combination of benefits often translates to a higher resale value.
Why don’t more people have metal roofs?
The most common roofing material is asphalt shingles, simply because it’s also the most affordable. However, metal roofs are catching on more, thanks to their ability to withstand the stormy weather found in the south, and the snowy weather found in the north.